Matchup Index

Buffalo Bills vs Indianapolis Colts

Buffalo Bills 39
Buffalo Bills leads 39-33-1
1 tie
1970 to 2024
Buffalo Bills won the last meeting
Indianapolis Colts 33

Series timeline

▲ Buffalo Bills ahead (peak +10) ▼ Indianapolis Colts ahead (peak +5)
1970: Tied 17-171970: Baltimore Colts 20-141971: Baltimore Colts 43-01971: Baltimore Colts 24-01972: Baltimore Colts 17-01972: Baltimore Colts 35-71973: Buffalo Bills 31-131973: Buffalo Bills 24-171974: Buffalo Bills 27-141974: Buffalo Bills 6-01975: Buffalo Bills 38-311975: Baltimore Colts 42-351976: Baltimore Colts 31-131976: Baltimore Colts 58-201977: Baltimore Colts 17-141977: Baltimore Colts 31-131978: Buffalo Bills 24-171978: Buffalo Bills 21-141979: Buffalo Bills 31-131979: Baltimore Colts 14-131980: Baltimore Colts 17-121980: Baltimore Colts 28-241981: Buffalo Bills 35-31981: Buffalo Bills 23-171982: Buffalo Bills 20-01983: Buffalo Bills 28-231983: Buffalo Bills 30-71984: Indianapolis Colts 31-171984: Buffalo Bills 21-151985: Indianapolis Colts 49-171985: Buffalo Bills 21-91986: Buffalo Bills 24-131986: Indianapolis Colts 24-141987: Indianapolis Colts 47-61987: Buffalo Bills 27-31988: Buffalo Bills 34-231988: Indianapolis Colts 17-141989: Indianapolis Colts 37-141989: Buffalo Bills 30-71990: Buffalo Bills 26-101990: Buffalo Bills 31-71991: Buffalo Bills 42-61991: Buffalo Bills 35-71992: Buffalo Bills 38-01992: Indianapolis Colts 16-131993: Buffalo Bills 23-91993: Buffalo Bills 30-101994: Indianapolis Colts 27-171994: Indianapolis Colts 10-91995: Buffalo Bills 20-141995: Buffalo Bills 16-101996: Buffalo Bills 16-131996: Indianapolis Colts 13-101997: Buffalo Bills 37-351997: Buffalo Bills 9-61998: Buffalo Bills 31-241998: Buffalo Bills 34-111999: Indianapolis Colts 31-141999: Buffalo Bills 31-62000: Indianapolis Colts 18-162000: Indianapolis Colts 44-202001: Indianapolis Colts 42-262001: Indianapolis Colts 30-142003: Indianapolis Colts 17-142006: Indianapolis Colts 17-162009: Buffalo Bills 30-72012: Indianapolis Colts 20-132015: Buffalo Bills 27-142017: Buffalo Bills 13-72018: Indianapolis Colts 37-52020: Buffalo Bills 27-24 (postseason)2021: Indianapolis Colts 41-152024: Buffalo Bills 30-20

Buffalo Bills Baltimore Colts Indianapolis Colts Tie Postseason One meeting per cell

Longest streaks: Buffalo Bills 6 (1989–1992), Indianapolis Colts 6 (2000–2006). Current: Buffalo Bills 1.

Splits

SplitBuffalo Bills record
Regular season38-33-1
Postseason1-0
Hosted by Buffalo Bills24-14
Hosted by Indianapolis Colts15-19-1
Last 10 seasons (2003 to 2024)5-5
Largest Buffalo Bills win38-0 (1992)
Largest Indianapolis Colts win43-0 (1971)

Postseason meetings

SeasonDateWinnerScoreSiteRound
2020Jan 9, 2021Buffalo Bills 27-24 at Buffalo Bills Wild Card

In the record book

Every meeting

2020s
SeasonDateWinnerScoreSiteRound
2024 Nov 10, 2024 Buffalo Bills 30-20 at Indianapolis Colts Week 10
2021 Nov 21, 2021 Indianapolis Colts 41-15 at Buffalo Bills Week 11
2020 Jan 9, 2021 Buffalo Bills 27-24 at Buffalo Bills Wild Card Postseason
2010s
SeasonDateWinnerScoreSiteRound
2018 Oct 21, 2018 Indianapolis Colts 37-5 at Indianapolis Colts Week 7
2017 Dec 10, 2017 Buffalo Bills 13-7 at Buffalo Bills Week 14
2015 Sep 13, 2015 Buffalo Bills 27-14 at Buffalo Bills Week 1
2012 Nov 25, 2012 Indianapolis Colts 20-13 at Indianapolis Colts Week 12
2000s
SeasonDateWinnerScoreSiteRound
2009 Jan 3, 2010 Buffalo Bills 30-7 at Buffalo Bills Week 17
2006 Nov 12, 2006 Indianapolis Colts 17-16 at Indianapolis Colts Week 10
2003 Nov 23, 2003 Indianapolis Colts 17-14 at Buffalo Bills Week 12
2001 (0-2) Sep 23, 2001 Indianapolis Colts 42-26 at Indianapolis Colts Week 2
Nov 4, 2001 Indianapolis Colts 30-14 at Buffalo Bills Week 8
2000 (0-2) Oct 1, 2000 Indianapolis Colts 18-16 at Buffalo Bills Week 5
Dec 11, 2000 Indianapolis Colts 44-20 at Indianapolis Colts Week 15
1990s
SeasonDateWinnerScoreSiteRound
1999 (1-1) Sep 12, 1999 Indianapolis Colts 31-14 at Indianapolis Colts Week 1
Jan 2, 2000 Buffalo Bills 31-6 at Buffalo Bills Week 17
1998 (2-0) Oct 11, 1998 Buffalo Bills 31-24 at Indianapolis Colts Week 6
Nov 22, 1998 Buffalo Bills 34-11 at Buffalo Bills Week 12
1997 (2-0) Sep 21, 1997 Buffalo Bills 37-35 at Buffalo Bills Week 4
Oct 20, 1997 Buffalo Bills 9-6 at Indianapolis Colts Week 8
1996 (1-1) Oct 6, 1996 Buffalo Bills 16-13 at Buffalo Bills Week 6
Dec 1, 1996 Indianapolis Colts 13-10 at Indianapolis Colts Week 14
1995 (2-0) Sep 17, 1995 Buffalo Bills 20-14 at Buffalo Bills Week 3
Nov 5, 1995 Buffalo Bills 16-10 at Indianapolis Colts Week 10
1994 (0-2) Oct 16, 1994 Indianapolis Colts 27-17 at Buffalo Bills Week 7
Dec 24, 1994 Indianapolis Colts 10-9 at Indianapolis Colts Week 17
1993 (2-0) Nov 21, 1993 Buffalo Bills 23-9 at Buffalo Bills Week 12
Jan 2, 1994 Buffalo Bills 30-10 at Indianapolis Colts Week 18
1992 (1-1) Sep 20, 1992 Buffalo Bills 38-0 at Buffalo Bills Week 3
Nov 29, 1992 Indianapolis Colts 16-13 at Indianapolis Colts Week 13
1991 (2-0) Oct 13, 1991 Buffalo Bills 42-6 at Buffalo Bills Week 7
Dec 15, 1991 Buffalo Bills 35-7 at Indianapolis Colts Week 16
1990 (2-0) Sep 9, 1990 Buffalo Bills 26-10 at Buffalo Bills Week 1
Dec 9, 1990 Buffalo Bills 31-7 at Indianapolis Colts Week 14
1980s
SeasonDateWinnerScoreSiteRound
1989 (1-1) Oct 8, 1989 Indianapolis Colts 37-14 at Indianapolis Colts Week 5
Nov 12, 1989 Buffalo Bills 30-7 at Buffalo Bills Week 10
1988 (1-1) Oct 9, 1988 Buffalo Bills 34-23 at Buffalo Bills Week 6
Dec 18, 1988 Indianapolis Colts 17-14 at Indianapolis Colts Week 16
1987 (1-1) Oct 4, 1987 Indianapolis Colts 47-6 at Buffalo Bills Week 4
Dec 13, 1987 Buffalo Bills 27-3 at Indianapolis Colts Week 14
1986 (1-1) Oct 19, 1986 Buffalo Bills 24-13 at Buffalo Bills Week 7
Dec 14, 1986 Indianapolis Colts 24-14 at Indianapolis Colts Week 15
1985 (1-1) Oct 6, 1985 Indianapolis Colts 49-17 at Indianapolis Colts Week 5
Oct 20, 1985 Buffalo Bills 21-9 at Buffalo Bills Week 7
1984 (1-1) Sep 30, 1984 Indianapolis Colts 31-17 at Indianapolis Colts Week 5
Dec 2, 1984 Buffalo Bills 21-15 at Buffalo Bills Week 14
1983 (2-0) Sep 18, 1983 Buffalo Bills 28-23 at Buffalo Bills Week 3
Oct 16, 1983 Buffalo Bills 30-7 at Baltimore Colts Week 7
1982 Nov 28, 1982 Buffalo Bills 20-0 at Buffalo Bills Week 12
1981 (2-0) Sep 13, 1981 Buffalo Bills 35-3 at Baltimore Colts Week 2
Oct 4, 1981 Buffalo Bills 23-17 at Buffalo Bills Week 5
1980 (0-2) Oct 12, 1980 Baltimore Colts 17-12 at Buffalo Bills Week 6
Nov 30, 1980 Baltimore Colts 28-24 at Baltimore Colts Week 13
1970s
SeasonDateWinnerScoreSiteRound
1979 (1-1) Sep 30, 1979 Buffalo Bills 31-13 at Baltimore Colts Week 5
Oct 21, 1979 Baltimore Colts 14-13 at Buffalo Bills Week 8
1978 (2-0) Sep 24, 1978 Buffalo Bills 24-17 at Buffalo Bills Week 4
Dec 17, 1978 Buffalo Bills 21-14 at Baltimore Colts Week 16
1977 (0-2) Oct 2, 1977 Baltimore Colts 17-14 at Baltimore Colts Week 3
Nov 13, 1977 Baltimore Colts 31-13 at Buffalo Bills Week 9
1976 (0-2) Oct 17, 1976 Baltimore Colts 31-13 at Buffalo Bills Week 6
Dec 12, 1976 Baltimore Colts 58-20 at Baltimore Colts Week 14
1975 (1-1) Oct 12, 1975 Buffalo Bills 38-31 at Baltimore Colts Week 4
Nov 9, 1975 Baltimore Colts 42-35 at Buffalo Bills Week 8
1974 (2-0) Oct 13, 1974 Buffalo Bills 27-14 at Baltimore Colts Week 5
Dec 1, 1974 Buffalo Bills 6-0 at Buffalo Bills Week 12
1973 (2-0) Oct 14, 1973 Buffalo Bills 31-13 at Buffalo Bills Week 5
Nov 25, 1973 Buffalo Bills 24-17 at Baltimore Colts Week 11
1972 (0-2) Oct 1, 1972 Baltimore Colts 17-0 at Buffalo Bills Week 3
Dec 3, 1972 Baltimore Colts 35-7 at Baltimore Colts Week 12
1971 (0-2) Oct 10, 1971 Baltimore Colts 43-0 at Buffalo Bills Week 4
Dec 5, 1971 Baltimore Colts 24-0 at Baltimore Colts Week 12
1970 (0-1-1) Nov 15, 1970 Tie 17-17 at Baltimore Colts Week 9
Dec 13, 1970 Baltimore Colts 20-14 at Buffalo Bills Week 13

Sources

Records are computed from every final game result in the Matchup Index database. About the data.