Matchup Index

Brooklyn Americans vs Toronto Maple Leafs

Brooklyn Americans 33
Toronto Maple Leafs leads 68-33-22
22 ties
1925-26 to 1941-42
Brooklyn Americans won the last meeting
Toronto Maple Leafs 68

Series timeline

▼ Toronto Maple Leafs ahead (peak +36)
1925-26: Toronto St. Patricks 5-31925-26: New York Americans 2-11925-26: Toronto St. Patricks 4-31925-26: Tied 1-11925-26: Toronto St. Patricks 3-21925-26: Toronto St. Patricks 4-21926-27: New York Americans 1-01926-27: New York Americans 2-01926-27: Toronto Maple Leafs 3-11926-27: Tied 0-01926-27: Toronto Maple Leafs 4-11926-27: Toronto Maple Leafs 4-11927-28: Toronto Maple Leafs 2-11927-28: Toronto Maple Leafs 5-21927-28: New York Americans 2-11927-28: Tied 2-21927-28: Toronto Maple Leafs 3-21927-28: Toronto Maple Leafs 4-21928-29: New York Americans 3-01928-29: Toronto Maple Leafs 3-01928-29: New York Americans 2-01928-29: New York Americans 1-01928-29: Toronto Maple Leafs 3-11928-29: Toronto Maple Leafs 5-01929-30: Toronto Maple Leafs 6-01929-30: New York Americans 1-01929-30: Tied 1-11929-30: Toronto Maple Leafs 4-11929-30: Toronto Maple Leafs 3-21929-30: Tied 1-11930-31: Tied 0-01930-31: Tied 0-01930-31: Toronto Maple Leafs 2-01930-31: New York Americans 3-21930-31: Toronto Maple Leafs 2-01930-31: Tied 1-11931-32: Tied 2-21931-32: Tied 2-21931-32: Toronto Maple Leafs 9-31931-32: Toronto Maple Leafs 5-01931-32: New York Americans 4-01931-32: Toronto Maple Leafs 11-31931-32: Tied 4-41931-32: Toronto Maple Leafs 3-11932-33: Tied 2-21932-33: New York Americans 1-01932-33: New York Americans 3-11932-33: Toronto Maple Leafs 7-11932-33: Toronto Maple Leafs 5-11932-33: New York Americans 4-31933-34: Toronto Maple Leafs 7-31933-34: Toronto Maple Leafs 9-11933-34: Tied 1-11933-34: Tied 2-21933-34: Tied 3-31933-34: Toronto Maple Leafs 8-51934-35: Toronto Maple Leafs 1-01934-35: Toronto Maple Leafs 4-31934-35: Toronto Maple Leafs 4-31934-35: Tied 5-51934-35: New York Americans 2-11934-35: Toronto Maple Leafs 6-01935-36: Tied 5-51935-36: New York Americans 4-21935-36: Toronto Maple Leafs 5-31935-36: New York Americans 3-21935-36: New York Americans 4-31935-36: Toronto Maple Leafs 3-01935-36: New York Americans 3-21935-36: Toronto Maple Leafs 4-11935-36: Toronto Maple Leafs 3-1 (postseason)1935-36: New York Americans 1-0 (postseason)1935-36: Toronto Maple Leafs 3-1 (postseason)1936-37: New York Americans 3-21936-37: Toronto Maple Leafs 5-11936-37: Toronto Maple Leafs 3-11936-37: New York Americans 6-31936-37: Toronto Maple Leafs 2-11936-37: Toronto Maple Leafs 5-01936-37: Toronto Maple Leafs 4-31936-37: New York Americans 3-11937-38: Toronto Maple Leafs 6-31937-38: Toronto Maple Leafs 3-21937-38: Toronto Maple Leafs 3-01937-38: Tied 1-11937-38: New York Americans 4-01937-38: Toronto Maple Leafs 3-21937-38: Toronto Maple Leafs 8-51937-38: New York Americans 4-21938-39: Toronto Maple Leafs 1-01938-39: New York Americans 2-11938-39: New York Americans 3-21938-39: New York Americans 5-11938-39: Toronto Maple Leafs 7-21938-39: New York Americans 4-11938-39: Tied 1-11938-39: Toronto Maple Leafs 7-31938-39: Toronto Maple Leafs 4-0 (postseason)1938-39: Toronto Maple Leafs 2-0 (postseason)1939-40: Toronto Maple Leafs 4-31939-40: New York Americans 2-11939-40: Toronto Maple Leafs 5-11939-40: Toronto Maple Leafs 4-11939-40: Toronto Maple Leafs 3-21939-40: Toronto Maple Leafs 5-11939-40: Toronto Maple Leafs 8-61939-40: New York Americans 5-21940-41: Toronto Maple Leafs 2-11940-41: Toronto Maple Leafs 6-11940-41: Tied 2-21940-41: New York Americans 2-11940-41: Toronto Maple Leafs 9-01940-41: Tied 3-31940-41: Tied 4-41940-41: Toronto Maple Leafs 6-11941-42: Toronto Maple Leafs 8-21941-42: Toronto Maple Leafs 5-11941-42: Brooklyn Americans 2-11941-42: Toronto Maple Leafs 4-21941-42: Toronto Maple Leafs 3-21941-42: Toronto Maple Leafs 4-31941-42: Toronto Maple Leafs 4-31941-42: Brooklyn Americans 6-3

New York Americans Brooklyn Americans Toronto St. Patricks Toronto Maple Leafs Tie Postseason One meeting per cell

Longest streaks: New York Americans 3 (1938-39), Toronto Maple Leafs 5 (1939-40). Current: Brooklyn Americans 1.

Splits

SplitBrooklyn Americans record
Regular season32-64-22
Postseason1-4
Hosted by Brooklyn Americans26-21-14
Hosted by Toronto Maple Leafs7-47-8
Last 10 seasons (1932-33 to 1941-42)23-45-11
Largest Brooklyn Americans win4-0 (1931-32)
Largest Toronto Maple Leafs win9-0 (1940-41)

Postseason meetings

SeasonDateWinnerScoreSiteRound
1938-39Mar 23, 1939Toronto Maple Leafs 2-0 at New York Americans
1938-39Mar 21, 1939Toronto Maple Leafs 4-0 at Toronto Maple Leafs
1935-36Apr 2, 1936Toronto Maple Leafs 3-1 at Toronto Maple Leafs
1935-36Mar 31, 1936New York Americans 1-0 at New York Americans
1935-36Mar 28, 1936Toronto Maple Leafs 3-1 at Toronto Maple Leafs

In the record book

Every meeting

1940s
SeasonDateWinnerScoreSiteRound
1941-42 (2-6) Nov 29, 1941 Toronto Maple Leafs 8-2 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Nov 30, 1941 Toronto Maple Leafs 5-1 at Brooklyn Americans
Dec 28, 1941 Brooklyn Americans 2-1 at Brooklyn Americans
Jan 3, 1942 Toronto Maple Leafs 4-2 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Jan 24, 1942 Toronto Maple Leafs 3-2 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Feb 8, 1942 Toronto Maple Leafs 4-3 at Brooklyn Americans
Feb 21, 1942 Toronto Maple Leafs 4-3 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Mar 15, 1942 Brooklyn Americans 6-3 at Brooklyn Americans
1940-41 (1-4-3) Nov 21, 1940 Toronto Maple Leafs 2-1 at New York Americans
Nov 30, 1940 Toronto Maple Leafs 6-1 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Dec 21, 1940 Tie 2-2 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Dec 22, 1940 New York Americans 2-1 at New York Americans
Jan 11, 1941 Toronto Maple Leafs 9-0 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Jan 19, 1941 Tie 3-3 at Brooklyn Americans
Feb 25, 1941 Tie 4-4 at Brooklyn Americans
Mar 8, 1941 Toronto Maple Leafs 6-1 at Toronto Maple Leafs
1930s
SeasonDateWinnerScoreSiteRound
1939-40 (2-6) Nov 25, 1939 Toronto Maple Leafs 4-3 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Nov 26, 1939 New York Americans 2-1 at New York Americans
Dec 16, 1939 Toronto Maple Leafs 5-1 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Dec 17, 1939 Toronto Maple Leafs 4-1 at New York Americans
Jan 9, 1940 Toronto Maple Leafs 3-2 at New York Americans
Jan 20, 1940 Toronto Maple Leafs 5-1 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Mar 16, 1940 Toronto Maple Leafs 8-6 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Mar 17, 1940 New York Americans 5-2 at New York Americans
1938-39 (4-5-1) Nov 17, 1938 Toronto Maple Leafs 1-0 at New York Americans
Nov 19, 1938 New York Americans 2-1 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Dec 31, 1938 New York Americans 3-2 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Jan 1, 1939 New York Americans 5-1 at New York Americans
Jan 21, 1939 Toronto Maple Leafs 7-2 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Jan 24, 1939 New York Americans 4-1 at New York Americans
Feb 28, 1939 Tie 1-1 at New York Americans
Mar 14, 1939 Toronto Maple Leafs 7-3 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Mar 21, 1939 Toronto Maple Leafs 4-0 at Toronto Maple Leafs Postseason
Mar 23, 1939 Toronto Maple Leafs 2-0 at New York Americans Postseason
1937-38 (2-5-1) Nov 6, 1937 Toronto Maple Leafs 6-3 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Dec 18, 1937 Toronto Maple Leafs 3-2 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Dec 28, 1937 Toronto Maple Leafs 3-0 at New York Americans
Jan 20, 1938 Tie 1-1 at New York Americans
Feb 19, 1938 New York Americans 4-0 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Feb 20, 1938 Toronto Maple Leafs 3-2 at New York Americans
Mar 19, 1938 Toronto Maple Leafs 8-5 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Mar 20, 1938 New York Americans 4-2 at New York Americans
1936-37 (3-5) Nov 7, 1936 New York Americans 3-2 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Dec 17, 1936 Toronto Maple Leafs 5-1 at New York Americans
Dec 19, 1936 Toronto Maple Leafs 3-1 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Jan 21, 1937 New York Americans 6-3 at New York Americans
Feb 4, 1937 Toronto Maple Leafs 2-1 at New York Americans
Feb 6, 1937 Toronto Maple Leafs 5-0 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Feb 20, 1937 Toronto Maple Leafs 4-3 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Feb 21, 1937 New York Americans 3-1 at New York Americans
1935-36 (5-5-1) Nov 9, 1935 Tie 5-5 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Dec 10, 1935 New York Americans 4-2 at New York Americans
Dec 21, 1935 Toronto Maple Leafs 5-3 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Jan 23, 1936 New York Americans 3-2 at New York Americans
Feb 6, 1936 New York Americans 4-3 at New York Americans
Feb 8, 1936 Toronto Maple Leafs 3-0 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Mar 10, 1936 New York Americans 3-2 at New York Americans
Mar 21, 1936 Toronto Maple Leafs 4-1 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Mar 28, 1936 Toronto Maple Leafs 3-1 at Toronto Maple Leafs Postseason
Mar 31, 1936 New York Americans 1-0 at New York Americans Postseason
Apr 2, 1936 Toronto Maple Leafs 3-1 at Toronto Maple Leafs Postseason
1934-35 (1-4-1) Nov 15, 1934 Toronto Maple Leafs 1-0 at New York Americans
Dec 15, 1934 Toronto Maple Leafs 4-3 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Dec 27, 1934 Toronto Maple Leafs 4-3 at New York Americans
Jan 10, 1935 Tie 5-5 at New York Americans
Feb 2, 1935 New York Americans 2-1 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Mar 2, 1935 Toronto Maple Leafs 6-0 at Toronto Maple Leafs
1933-34 (0-3-3) Nov 28, 1933 Toronto Maple Leafs 7-3 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Dec 5, 1933 Toronto Maple Leafs 9-1 at New York Americans
Jan 11, 1934 Tie 1-1 at New York Americans
Jan 13, 1934 Tie 2-2 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Feb 8, 1934 Tie 3-3 at New York Americans
Mar 10, 1934 Toronto Maple Leafs 8-5 at Toronto Maple Leafs
1932-33 (3-2-1) Dec 10, 1932 Tie 2-2 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Dec 22, 1932 New York Americans 1-0 at New York Americans
Jan 17, 1933 New York Americans 3-1 at New York Americans
Jan 31, 1933 Toronto Maple Leafs 7-1 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Feb 25, 1933 Toronto Maple Leafs 5-1 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Mar 21, 1933 New York Americans 4-3 at New York Americans
1931-32 (1-4-3) Dec 1, 1931 Tie 2-2 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Dec 15, 1931 Tie 2-2 at New York Americans
Dec 22, 1931 Toronto Maple Leafs 9-3 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Dec 29, 1931 Toronto Maple Leafs 5-0 at New York Americans
Jan 17, 1932 New York Americans 4-0 at New York Americans
Jan 19, 1932 Toronto Maple Leafs 11-3 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Feb 23, 1932 Tie 4-4 at New York Americans
Mar 1, 1932 Toronto Maple Leafs 3-1 at Toronto Maple Leafs
1930-31 (1-2-3) Nov 13, 1930 Tie 0-0 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Nov 20, 1930 Tie 0-0 at New York Americans
Jan 1, 1931 Toronto Maple Leafs 2-0 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Jan 27, 1931 New York Americans 3-2 at New York Americans
Feb 7, 1931 Toronto Maple Leafs 2-0 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Feb 24, 1931 Tie 1-1 at New York Americans
1920s
SeasonDateWinnerScoreSiteRound
1929-30 (1-3-2) Dec 3, 1929 Toronto Maple Leafs 6-0 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Dec 10, 1929 New York Americans 1-0 at New York Americans
Jan 7, 1930 Tie 1-1 at New York Americans
Jan 18, 1930 Toronto Maple Leafs 4-1 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Feb 9, 1930 Toronto Maple Leafs 3-2 at New York Americans
Mar 4, 1930 Tie 1-1 at Toronto Maple Leafs
1928-29 (3-3) Nov 22, 1928 New York Americans 3-0 at New York Americans
Dec 1, 1928 Toronto Maple Leafs 3-0 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Jan 10, 1929 New York Americans 2-0 at New York Americans
Jan 12, 1929 New York Americans 1-0 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Feb 3, 1929 Toronto Maple Leafs 3-1 at New York Americans
Mar 14, 1929 Toronto Maple Leafs 5-0 at Toronto Maple Leafs
1927-28 (1-4-1) Nov 24, 1927 Toronto Maple Leafs 2-1 at New York Americans
Dec 20, 1927 Toronto Maple Leafs 5-2 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Jan 10, 1928 New York Americans 2-1 at New York Americans
Feb 11, 1928 Tie 2-2 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Feb 16, 1928 Toronto Maple Leafs 3-2 at New York Americans
Mar 8, 1928 Toronto Maple Leafs 4-2 at Toronto Maple Leafs
1926-27 (2-3-1) Dec 4, 1926 New York Americans 1-0 at Toronto St. Patricks
Dec 20, 1926 New York Americans 2-0 at New York Americans
Jan 8, 1927 Toronto Maple Leafs 3-1 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Feb 3, 1927 Tie 0-0 at New York Americans
Feb 17, 1927 Toronto Maple Leafs 4-1 at Toronto Maple Leafs
Mar 21, 1927 Toronto Maple Leafs 4-1 at New York Americans
1925-26 (1-4-1) Dec 5, 1925 Toronto St. Patricks 5-3 at Toronto St. Patricks
Dec 30, 1925 New York Americans 2-1 at New York Americans
Jan 15, 1926 Toronto St. Patricks 4-3 at Toronto St. Patricks
Feb 3, 1926 Tie 1-1 at New York Americans
Feb 16, 1926 Toronto St. Patricks 3-2 at New York Americans
Mar 6, 1926 Toronto St. Patricks 4-2 at Toronto St. Patricks

Sources

Records are computed from every final game result in the Matchup Index database. About the data.